Having gone through the Rite of Acceptance during RCIA 2 weekends ago, I was a little perplexed (and insulted) when my friend insisted that Catholics are not Christians when I met her for lunch over the weekend.
Her argument:
1) We have the Pope, and he is most certainly Catholic because there is no Pope in Christianity
2) We have Mother Mary
3) The teachings are different (but but... isn't that the case for all the different denominations?)
4) There are many denominations under Christianity but Catholicism is an entirely different branch and most certainly not part of the "Christian" umbrella
5) The way we have communion is different
6) In Chinese the 2 are called differently: "天主教" vs "基督教" hence they are 2 entirely different religions
We were taught at RCIA that Catholics are Christians so to me it was like... North and South Korea being at loggerheads at each other. Haha not the best analogy but both believe in God and Jesus so.... why the insistence?
Turned to good ol' Google and the conclusion is:
All Catholics are Christians, but not all Christians are Catholics.
(
http://www.diffen.com/difference/Catholicism_vs_Christianity)
But then I also found another page declaring that Roman Catholicism and Christianity are not the same so.... *shrug*
Most certainly there will be different things taught and I do not know what is being taught to Protestant Christians (myth buster - I was taught during RCIA that we do not worship Mother Mary). But different and distinct religions to me would mean something like Christianity vs Buddhism vs Hinduism.
So anyway, after the Rite of Acceptance, I am called a "catechumen" instead of an "inquirer". How do I feel about this "upgrade"? Haha. I don't feel much about it at this point to be honest. Then again, I'm not someone who has very strong faith (religion to me was never a necessity). So yep. Going along because my husband-to-be happens to be Catholic. Just something that I have to go through.
If I were to compare this to 2 years ago when I was very very very reluctant to turn Christian... on hindsight I think it was a good thing because certainly there was a mismatch, or a perhaps a sign of better things to come in future. Because really, all that was stopping it from progressing further (and also caused much angst) was the religion issue. In contrast, I see many many good qualities in Paul that will allow him to be a good husband and leader of the house. And he has been very happy to try to explain my sometimes silly questions about his religion. Least I can do is to try and understand his faith.
- Follow me on Twitter!
- "Join Us on Facebook!
- RSS
Contact